HomeCBSEClass 10Social_Economics › Power-sharing
CBSE · Class 10 · 📘 Social_Economics · Chapter 1

Power-sharing

Power-sharingMajoritarianismBelgian ModelHorizontal Power SharingVertical Power SharingCommunity Government

The chapter 'Power-sharing' introduces students to the concept of power distribution in democracies, using case studies of Belgium and Sri Lanka. It explores how different approaches to power-sharing can lead to either stability or conflict. Students learn about prudential and moral reasons for power-sharing, and various forms such as horizontal, vertical, community government, and power-sharing among political parties and pressure groups. Understanding these concepts is crucial for comprehending the functioning of democratic governments and maintaining social harmony.

Introduction to Power-sharing

Democracy mein, power kisi ek organ ke paas nahi hoti. Power ko legislature, executive aur judiciary ke beech intelligently share karna bahut important hai. Is chapter mein hum power-sharing ke idea ko explore karenge, especially Belgium aur Sri Lanka ke examples se.

  • Power-sharing ka basic idea: Government ki power ko different levels, organs, aur social groups mein distribute karna.
  • Goal: Social conflicts ko reduce karna aur political stability maintain karna.
  • Democracy ka core principle: People are the source of all political power. Isliye, power ko jitna ho sake, citizens ke beech distribute karna chahiye.
Important

Power-sharing democracy ki spirit hai. Isse government mein sabhi groups ki participation ensure hoti hai.

Case Study: Belgium's Ethnic Composition and Tensions

Belgium Europe ka ek chhota sa country hai, Haryana se bhi chhota. Iski population lagbhag 1 crore hai.

  • Ethnic Composition:
  • Flemish region (59%): Dutch-speaking.
  • Wallonia region (40%): French-speaking.
  • Remaining 1%: German-speaking.
  • Capital City Brussels:
  • 80% French-speaking.
  • 20% Dutch-speaking.
  • Tensions ke Reasons:
  • French-speaking minority relatively rich aur powerful thi.
  • Dutch-speaking community ko economic development aur education ka benefit bahut baad mein mila, jisse unmein resentment tha.
  • 1950s aur 1960s mein Dutch aur French-speaking communities ke beech tensions badh gaye.
  • Brussels mein situation aur complex thi: Country mein Dutch majority mein the, but capital mein minority mein.
Remember

Belgium mein, country level par Dutch majority mein the, but capital Brussels mein French majority mein the. Ye ek unique situation thi.

Case Study: Sri Lanka's Ethnic Composition and Tensions

Sri Lanka ek island nation hai, Tamil Nadu ke south coast se kuch kilometers door. Iski population lagbhag 2 crore hai.

  • Ethnic Composition:
  • Sinhala-speakers (74%): Majority.
  • Tamil-speakers (18%): Minority.
  • Sri Lankan Tamils (13%): Country ke native Tamils, mostly North aur East mein concentrated.
  • Indian Tamils (5%): Colonial period mein India se plantation workers ke roop mein aaye the.
  • Religious Composition:
  • Most Sinhala-speaking log Buddhists hain.
  • Most Tamils Hindus ya Muslims hain.
  • 7% Christians hain, jo Tamil aur Sinhala dono hain.
  • Potential Conflict:
  • Sinhala community apni large majority ka fayda utha kar poore country par apna will impose kar sakti thi.
  • Isse minority Tamils mein alienation aur conflict badh sakta tha.
Important

Sri Lanka ki ethnic diversity mein Sinhala (Buddhist majority) aur Tamil (Hindu/Muslim minority) ke beech ka division major tha.

Majoritarianism and Civil War in Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka 1948 mein independent hua. Sinhala community ke leaders ne apni majority ke bal par government par dominance establish karne ki koshish ki. Is approach ko Majoritarianism kehte hain.

  • Majoritarian Measures (1956 ke baad):
  • 1956 Act: Sinhala ko sole official language declare kiya, Tamil ko disregard kiya.
  • Preferential Policies: Sinhala applicants ko university positions aur government jobs mein priority di gayi.
  • New Constitution: State ne Buddhism ko protect aur foster karne ka stipulate kiya.
  • Effects on Sri Lankan Tamils:
  • Feeling of alienation badh gayi.
  • Unhone mehsoos kiya ki unki language aur culture ko respect nahi kiya ja raha hai.
  • Unhein equal political rights, jobs aur opportunities se deny kiya ja raha tha.
  • Struggle aur Civil War:
  • Sri Lankan Tamils ne Tamil ko official language banane, regional autonomy aur equality of opportunity ke liye struggles launch kiye.
  • Unki autonomy ki demands ko repeatedly deny kiya gaya.
  • 1980s tak, independent Tamil Eelam (state) ki demand ke liye political organisations ban gaye.
  • Distrust badh kar widespread conflict aur civil war mein badal gaya.
  • Civil war 2009 mein khatam hua, jisse country ko social, cultural aur economic setback mila.
📖Definition

Majoritarianism: Ek belief ki majority community ko country ko rule karna chahiye, jismein wo minority communities ki wishes aur needs ko disregard kar sake.

Important

Sri Lanka ka example dikhata hai ki agar majority community power share karne se mana karti hai, toh country ki unity undermine ho sakti hai aur civil war jaisi situation create ho sakti hai.

The Belgian Model of Accommodation

Belgium ke leaders ne Sri Lanka se alag approach apnaya. Unhone regional differences aur cultural diversities ko recognize kiya aur mutually acceptable arrangements banaye.

  • Constitutional Amendments: 1970 aur 1993 ke beech, unhone apne constitution ko chaar baar amend kiya taaki sab log ek saath reh sakein.
  • Key Elements of Belgian Model:
  1. Central Government:
  • Dutch aur French-speaking ministers ki equal number hogi.
  • Special laws ke liye har linguistic group ke majority members ka support zaroori hai. Koi ek community unilaterally decisions nahi le sakti.
  1. State Governments:
  • Central Government ki kai powers State Governments ko di gayi.
  • State Governments Central Government ke subordinate nahi hain.
  1. Brussels ki Separate Government:
  • Brussels mein both communities ka equal representation hai.
  • French-speaking logon ne Brussels mein equal representation accept kiya, kyunki Dutch-speaking community ne Central Government mein equal representation accept kiya tha.
  1. Community Government:
  • Ye third kind ki government hai.
  • Ek particular language community (Dutch, French, German) ke logon dwara elect ki jaati hai, irrespective of where they live.
  • Iske paas cultural, educational aur language-related issues par power hai.
  • Outcome:
  • Ye model complicated lag sakta hai, but isne civic strife ko avoid kiya aur country ko linguistic lines par divide hone se bachaya.
  • Brussels ko European Union ka headquarters chuna gaya, jo is model ki success ka proof hai.
💡Tip

Belgian model ke char main features ko yaad rakhein. Ye board exams mein frequently pucha jata hai.

Why Power Sharing is Desirable: Prudential and Moral Reasons

Belgium aur Sri Lanka ke examples se hum seekhte hain ki power sharing kyun desirable hai. Iske do main reasons hain:

  • 1. Prudential Reasons (समझदारी वाले कारण):
  • Ye reasons outcomes par based hote hain.
  • Conflict Reduction: Power sharing social groups ke beech conflict ki possibility ko kam karta hai. Social conflict se violence aur political instability ho sakti hai.
  • Political Stability: Power sharing political order ki stability ensure karta hai.
  • Long-term Unity: Majority community ka will impose karna short-term mein attractive lag sakta hai, but long-term mein nation ki unity ko undermine karta hai.
  • Tyranny of Majority: Majority ki tyranny sirf minority ke liye oppressive nahi hoti, balki majority ko bhi adversely affect karti hai.
  • 2. Moral Reasons (नैतिक कारण):
  • Ye reasons power sharing ke act ko hi valuable mante hain.
  • Spirit of Democracy: Power sharing democracy ki very spirit hai. Democratic rule mein power un logon ke saath share ki jaati hai jo usse affected hote hain.
  • Citizen Participation: Logon ko ye decide karne ka right hai ki unhein kaise govern kiya jayega.
  • Legitimate Government: Ek legitimate government woh hoti hai jismein citizens participation ke through system mein stake acquire karte hain.
Important

Prudential reasons stress karte hain ki power sharing se better outcomes milenge, jabki moral reasons power sharing ko inherently valuable mante hain.

Case Study: Khalil’s Dilemma and Lebanon's Power Sharing

Khalil ki story Lebanon ke power-sharing model ko highlight karti hai, jo civil war ke baad develop kiya gaya tha.

  • Lebanon ka Context:
  • Beirut, Lebanon ki capital, ek cosmopolitan city hai jahan various communities rehti hain.
  • Yahan ek bitter civil war hua tha.
  • Lebanon ka Power-sharing Agreement (Civil War ke baad):
  • President: Maronite sect ke Catholic Christian se hoga.
  • Prime Minister: Sunni Muslim community se hoga.
  • Deputy Prime Minister: Orthodox Christian sect ke liye fixed.
  • Speaker: Shi’a Muslim ke liye fixed.
  • Is pact mein Christians ne French protection na seekhne aur Muslims ne Syria ke saath unification na seekhne par agree kiya.
  • Ye agreement tab bana jab Christians aur Muslims ki population nearly equal thi, although ab Muslims clear majority mein hain.
  • Khalil ka Dilemma:
  • Khalil ko ye system pasand nahi hai, kyunki uski political ambition hai, but top position uski reach se bahar hai.
  • Wo chahta hai ki Lebanon bhi 'normal' democracy ki tarah ho, jahan elections hon aur jo maximum votes jeete wo president bane, irrespective of community.
  • Uske elders, jinhone civil war dekha hai, mante hain ki ye system peace ki best guarantee hai.
Remember

Lebanon ka model power sharing among different social groups ka ek example hai, jahan specific posts ko specific religious communities ke liye reserve kiya gaya hai.

Forms of Power Sharing in Modern Democracies

Modern democracies mein power sharing arrangements kai forms le sakte hain. Ye undivided political power ke notions ke opposition mein evolve hue hain.

  • 1. Horizontal Distribution of Power (सरकार के विभिन्न अंगों के बीच):
  • Power legislature, executive aur judiciary jaise government ke different organs ke beech share ki jaati hai.
  • Ye same level par different powers exercise karne ki permission deta hai.
  • Checks and Balances System: Har organ doosre ko check karta hai, jisse balance of power maintain hota hai aur koi bhi organ unlimited power exercise nahi kar sakta.
  • Example: India mein judiciary executive aur legislature ke functioning ko check karti hai.
  • 2. Vertical Distribution of Power (सरकार के विभिन्न स्तरों के बीच):
  • Power governments ke different levels ke beech share ki jaati hai: general government (Central/Union) aur provincial/regional governments (State).
  • Isse federal division of power kehte hain.
  • Constitution clearly har level ki government ki powers ko define karta hai.
  • Example: India mein Union Government aur State Governments hain. Belgium mein bhi aisa hi hua, Sri Lanka mein nahi.
  • Ye division State government se lower levels tak bhi extend ho sakta hai, jaise municipality aur panchayat.
  • 3. Power Sharing among Different Social Groups (विभिन्न सामाजिक समूहों के बीच):
  • Power religious aur linguistic groups jaise different social groups ke beech share ki jaati hai.
  • Example: Belgium mein Community Government. India mein reserved constituencies ka system, jisse socially weaker sections aur women ko representation milta hai.
  • Iska aim hai ki diverse social groups ko government aur administration mein space mile, aur wo alienated feel na karein.
  • 4. Power Sharing among Political Parties, Pressure Groups and Movements (राजनीतिक दलों, दबाव समूहों और आंदोलनों के बीच):
  • Democracy mein citizens ko power ke various contenders mein se choose karne ki freedom hoti hai.
  • Competition among Parties: Ye ensure karta hai ki power kisi ek haath mein na rahe.
  • Coalition Governments: Jab do ya do se zyada parties elections contest karne ke liye alliance banati hain aur jeetne par coalition government form karti hain, toh wo power share karti hain.
  • Interest Groups: Traders, businessmen, farmers, industrial workers jaise interest groups bhi governmental power mein share karte hain, ya toh governmental committees mein participate karke ya decision-making process ko influence karke.
💡Tip

Forms of power sharing ek bahut important topic hai. Har form ko example ke saath explain karna seekhein.

Ask SAAVI — Free